Statutory SEBI Portfolio Analysis

SBI Nifty Index Fund vs Parag Parikh Flexi Cap Fund

Portfolio Overlap, Shared Stock Holdings & Redundant Fee Drainage Analysis

⚡ Direct Overlap Summary (SEBI Filings)

As of the latest statutory mutual fund disclosures, SBI Nifty Index Fund and Parag Parikh Flexi Cap Fund have a 34.9% weighted portfolio overlap across 11 common stocks. MakeFinSense classifies this pairing as 🟡 CATEGORY DRIFT (Cross-Category Overlap — Monitor Style Drift). Cross-category overlap (34.9% between Index and Flexi Cap). One fund is encroaching on the other's market-cap mandate with low divergence. Monitor allocation drift. Holding both schemes in a ₹2,00,000 combined allocation leads to approx ₹34,900 in duplicate stock exposure and ₹52/year in avoidable fee drag.

Weighted Overlap
34.9%
Shared Stock Count
11
Avoidable Fee Drag
₹52 / yr
Tournament Winner
Parag Parikh Flexi Cap Fund
Top Common Stock Holdings
Stocks held simultaneously by both schemes (Minimum overlapping weights).
11 Total Common Stocks
Stock Company Sector SBI Nifty Index Fund Wt Parag Parikh Flexi... Wt Overlap Wt
HDFC Bank Ltd. Financial Services 9.85% 7.63% 7.63%
ICICI Bank Ltd. Financial Services 9.45% 5.67% 5.67%
Infosys Ltd. Technology 3.61% 3.29% 3.29%
Axis Bank Ltd. Financial Services 3.39% 2.97% 2.97%
Bharti Airtel Ltd. Telecommunication 5.00% 2.80% 2.80%
Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd. Financial Services 2.80% 4.40% 2.80%
Mahindra & Mahindra Ltd. Diversified 2.66% 3.97% 2.66%
ITC Ltd. Consumer Goods 2.24% 5.26% 2.24%
Tata Consultancy Services Ltd. Technology 2.22% 2.88% 2.22%
Maruti Suzuki India Ltd. Automobile 1.60% 2.68% 1.60%
Coal India Ltd. Metals & Mining 0.97% 5.02% 0.97%

Frequently Asked Questions

How is the 34.9% overlap between these two funds calculated?

MakeFinSense applies the institutional weighted minimum formula: for every company held by both funds, we take the minimum of its percentage weight in Fund 1 and Fund 2, and sum them together. This guarantees that duplicate capital is accurately assessed down to the exact basis point.

Does high overlap mean I should sell one of the funds?

Not automatically. If the overlap is above 35% with low sector divergence, they are essentially closet clones charging double expense ratios. In that scenario, consolidating into the tournament winner (Parag Parikh Flexi Cap Fund) eliminates unnecessary fee leakage and simplifies capital gains tax reporting.

Can I test my actual portfolio against these funds?

Yes. You can upload your Consolidated Account Statement (CAS) PDF into our local-first portfolio audit tool to check pairwise collisions across all your active folios without your data ever leaving your browser.

Compare Custom Mutual Funds or Audit Your Entire Folio

Test any 2 to 8 funds head-to-head in our live interactive analyzer or upload your CAMS / KFintech CAS PDF for a complete portfolio declutter audit.

⚡ Open Live Overlap Calculator 📄 Audit Full CAS Statement
More Comparisons
Parag vs SBI ICICI vs ICICI SBI vs SBI Quant vs ICICI ICICI vs ICICI SBI vs SBI