Institutional AMC Research

SBI: Thematic vs. Core Fund Alpha & Risk Analysis

Statutory disclosure evaluation of 9 thematic schemes against 1 core diversified funds.

Published: 2026-11-05 • By MakeFinSense Quantitative Research Desk • Source: SEBI Monthly Disclosures
⚡ Key Takeaways for Investors

Analysis of SBI shows that most thematic and sectoral funds share significant overlapping holdings with standard large and flexi-cap core funds. To justify the higher Total Expense Ratio (TER) and sectoral volatility, a thematic fund must generate an Active Delta of at least 70% and positive net alpha. In this study, 9 of 9 pairings demonstrated justifiable standalone value, while the remainder resulted in unjustified fee drag.

Statutory Overlap & Active Delta Matrix
Pairwise overlap, active share divergence, alpha delta, and tournament recommendations.
Thematic Scheme Core Benchmark Overlap Active Delta Alpha Delta Effective TER Score Winner Verdict
Technology Opportunities Fund Large Cap Fund 7.7% 92.3% -0.96% 0.65% Large Cap Fund 🔴 UNJUSTIFIED THEME DRAG
Healthcare Opportunities Fund Large Cap Fund 5.5% 94.5% -1.04% 0.65% Large Cap Fund 🔴 UNJUSTIFIED THEME DRAG
Infrastructure Fund Large Cap Fund 12.7% 87.3% +0.08% 0.88% Infrastructure Fund 🔴 UNJUSTIFIED THEME DRAG
PSU Fund Large Cap Fund 3.7% 96.3% -0.64% 0.65% Large Cap Fund 🔴 UNJUSTIFIED THEME DRAG
Banking and PSU Debt Fund Large Cap Fund 3.7% 96.3% -1.33% 0.65% Banking and PSU Debt Fund 🔴 UNJUSTIFIED THEME DRAG
Banking And Financial Services Fund Large Cap Fund 24.4% 75.6% +0.08% 0.65% Banking And Financial Services Fund 🔴 UNJUSTIFIED THEME DRAG
Energy Opportunities Fund Large Cap Fund 3.6% 96.4% -0.56% 0.65% Large Cap Fund 🔴 UNJUSTIFIED THEME DRAG
Nifty Bank Index Fund Large Cap Fund 27% 73% -2.44% -0.03% Large Cap Fund 🔴 UNJUSTIFIED THEME DRAG
BSE PSU Bank Index Fund Large Cap Fund 3.7% 96.3% -1.32% 0.13% Large Cap Fund 🔴 UNJUSTIFIED THEME DRAG

Top Overlapping Core Stocks

The primary reason for thematic overlap is index gravitation—fund managers allocating heavily to top Nifty 50 large-cap bellwethers within sectoral mandates:

Audit Your Mutual Funds Against SBI

Check if your current mutual fund portfolio collides with these schemes or upload your CAS statement to detect hidden clone holdings.

⚡ Check Mutual Fund Overlap Free 📄 Run Full Portfolio CAS Audit