Statutory disclosure evaluation of 10 thematic schemes against 3 core diversified funds.
Analysis of ICICI Prudential shows that most thematic and sectoral funds share significant overlapping holdings with standard large and flexi-cap core funds. To justify the higher Total Expense Ratio (TER) and sectoral volatility, a thematic fund must generate an Active Delta of at least 70% and positive net alpha. In this study, 30 of 30 pairings demonstrated justifiable standalone value, while the remainder resulted in unjustified fee drag.
| Thematic Scheme | Core Benchmark | Overlap | Active Delta | Alpha Delta | Effective TER | Score Winner | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Infrastructure Fund - Direct Plan - Growth | Flexi Cap Fund | 0% | 100% | -0.17% | 0.55% | Flexi Cap Fund | 🔴 UNJUSTIFIED THEME DRAG |
| Infrastructure Fund - Direct Plan - Growth | Large Cap Fund | 18.4% | 81.6% | +0.08% | 0.53% | Large Cap Fund | 🔴 UNJUSTIFIED THEME DRAG |
| Infrastructure Fund - Direct Plan - Growth | Multi Cap Fund | 2.5% | 97.5% | -0.64% | 0.55% | Multi Cap Fund | 🔴 UNJUSTIFIED THEME DRAG |
| Banking & Financial Services Fund | Flexi Cap Fund | 14.6% | 85.4% | -0.49% | 0.65% | Flexi Cap Fund | 🔴 UNJUSTIFIED THEME DRAG |
| Banking & Financial Services Fund | Large Cap Fund | 26.2% | 73.8% | -0.24% | 0.65% | Large Cap Fund | 🔴 UNJUSTIFIED THEME DRAG |
| Banking & Financial Services Fund | Multi Cap Fund | 3.1% | 96.9% | -0.96% | 0.65% | Multi Cap Fund | 🔴 UNJUSTIFIED THEME DRAG |
| Banking and PSU Debt Fund | Flexi Cap Fund | 3% | 97% | -1.74% | 0.65% | Flexi Cap Fund | 🔴 UNJUSTIFIED THEME DRAG |
| Banking and PSU Debt Fund | Large Cap Fund | 3% | 97% | -1.49% | 0.65% | Large Cap Fund | 🔴 UNJUSTIFIED THEME DRAG |
| Banking and PSU Debt Fund | Multi Cap Fund | 0% | 100% | -2.21% | 0.65% | Multi Cap Fund | 🔴 UNJUSTIFIED THEME DRAG |
| Commodities Fund | Flexi Cap Fund | 0% | 100% | +0.07% | 0.65% | Flexi Cap Fund | 🔴 UNJUSTIFIED THEME DRAG |
| Commodities Fund | Large Cap Fund | 4.4% | 95.6% | +0.32% | 0.65% | Commodities Fund | 🔴 UNJUSTIFIED THEME DRAG |
| Commodities Fund | Multi Cap Fund | 11.2% | 88.8% | -0.4% | 0.65% | Multi Cap Fund | 🔴 UNJUSTIFIED THEME DRAG |
| Energy Opportunities Fund | Flexi Cap Fund | 0% | 100% | -0.01% | 0.65% | Flexi Cap Fund | 🔴 UNJUSTIFIED THEME DRAG |
| Energy Opportunities Fund | Large Cap Fund | 10.1% | 89.9% | +0.24% | 0.65% | Energy Opportunities Fund | 🔴 UNJUSTIFIED THEME DRAG |
| Energy Opportunities Fund | Multi Cap Fund | 2% | 98% | -0.48% | 0.65% | Multi Cap Fund | 🔴 UNJUSTIFIED THEME DRAG |
| FMCG Fund | Flexi Cap Fund | 2.8% | 97.2% | +0.23% | 0.65% | FMCG Fund | 🔴 UNJUSTIFIED THEME DRAG |
| FMCG Fund | Large Cap Fund | 1.1% | 98.9% | +0.48% | 0.65% | FMCG Fund | 🔴 UNJUSTIFIED THEME DRAG |
| FMCG Fund | Multi Cap Fund | 0% | 100% | -0.24% | 0.65% | FMCG Fund | 🔴 UNJUSTIFIED THEME DRAG |
| Healthcare Fund | Flexi Cap Fund | 0% | 100% | -0.09% | 0.65% | Flexi Cap Fund | 🔴 UNJUSTIFIED THEME DRAG |
| Healthcare Fund | Large Cap Fund | 2.2% | 97.8% | +0.16% | 0.65% | Large Cap Fund | 🔴 UNJUSTIFIED THEME DRAG |
| Healthcare Fund | Multi Cap Fund | 1.6% | 98.4% | -0.56% | 0.65% | Multi Cap Fund | 🔴 UNJUSTIFIED THEME DRAG |
| HOUSING OPPORTUNITIES FUND | Flexi Cap Fund | 13.8% | 86.2% | -0.41% | 0.65% | Flexi Cap Fund | 🔴 UNJUSTIFIED THEME DRAG |
| HOUSING OPPORTUNITIES FUND | Large Cap Fund | 28.5% | 71.5% | -0.16% | 0.65% | Large Cap Fund | 🔴 UNJUSTIFIED THEME DRAG |
| HOUSING OPPORTUNITIES FUND | Multi Cap Fund | 5.5% | 94.5% | -0.88% | 0.65% | Multi Cap Fund | 🔴 UNJUSTIFIED THEME DRAG |
| Manufacturing Fund | Flexi Cap Fund | 8% | 92% | +0.47% | 0.65% | Manufacturing Fund | 🔴 UNJUSTIFIED THEME DRAG |
| Manufacturing Fund | Large Cap Fund | 19.4% | 80.6% | +0.72% | 0.65% | Manufacturing Fund | 🟢 THEME JUSTIFIED |
| Manufacturing Fund | Multi Cap Fund | 9.8% | 90.2% | +0% | 0.65% | Manufacturing Fund | 🔴 UNJUSTIFIED THEME DRAG |
| Nifty Bank Index Fund | Flexi Cap Fund | 15.7% | 84.3% | -1.97% | 0.06% | Flexi Cap Fund | 🔴 UNJUSTIFIED THEME DRAG |
| Nifty Bank Index Fund | Large Cap Fund | 25.2% | 74.8% | -1.72% | -0.02% | Large Cap Fund | 🔴 UNJUSTIFIED THEME DRAG |
| Nifty Bank Index Fund | Multi Cap Fund | 0% | 100% | -2.44% | 0.15% | Multi Cap Fund | 🔴 UNJUSTIFIED THEME DRAG |
The primary reason for thematic overlap is index gravitation—fund managers allocating heavily to top Nifty 50 large-cap bellwethers within sectoral mandates:
Check if your current mutual fund portfolio collides with these schemes or upload your CAS statement to detect hidden clone holdings.