FIRST SIP • AMC CONCENTRATION

Can I Invest in 3 Funds From the Same Fund House?

Fiduciary Verdict in 30 Seconds
While legal and operationally simple, buying multiple equity funds from one AMC often creates high stock overlap (25-45%) because schemes share the same chief investment officer (CIO), analyst desk, and institutional house views.

The Real Dilemma Behind the Question

When opening a mutual fund account through your primary bank (SBI, HDFC, ICICI, or Kotak), the bank relationship manager or mobile app makes it effortless to pick schemes under their own brand:

"Sir, take our Bluechip Fund for safety, our Flexi Cap for growth, and our Thematic/Value Fund for extra returns."

It feels organized to see one single AMC logo on all your investment statements. But a lingering question remains: **"If all three funds are run by the same company, am I actually diversified, or did I just buy three different wrappers around the same investment committee?"**

The Hard Numbers: What Disclosures Reveal

25% - 48%
Intra-AMC Stock Overlap
Average overlap between core equity funds within the same AMC
Single CIO Desk
Shared Analyst Coverage
Stock models approved by one institutional investment committee
High Correlation
House View Bias
If the AMC turns bearish on IT or Banks, all three schemes tilt similarly
1 Consolidated Folio
Operational Convenience
Single KYC, single statement, easier nominee management

The AMC Reality (Why Fund Managers Do This)

AMCs are structured with centralized equity research desks. Here is how that affects your portfolio:
  • The House Model Portfolio: Top AMCs employ 20-40 equity analysts led by a Chief Investment Officer (CIO). When the desk rates a stock like Larsen & Toubro or Axis Bank as a "High Conviction Buy", that stock gets injected across the Large Cap fund, the Flexi Cap fund, and the Balanced Advantage fund simultaneously.
  • Different Mandates, Same Swimming Pool: Even though the funds have different names, SEBI defines standard market capitalization boundaries (Top 100 for Large, 101-250 for Mid). Fund managers across different desks inside the same AMC frequently buy the same top-scoring companies from their internal research universe.
The Verdict: AMCs do not do this to deceive investors; they do it because institutional research is centralized. However, as an investor, owning 3 equity schemes from one AMC gives you style concentration, not genuine multi-manager diversification.

Test Intra-AMC Scheme Clashes

Check the real statutory overlap between ICICI Large Cap and ICICI Flexi Cap (25.1% overlap) or SBI Contra vs SBI Focused Fund.

⚡ Audit ICICI Large Cap vs Flexi Cap Overlap

Action Plan: How to Structure Your Portfolio

1. Diversify Investment Philosophies, Not Just Schemes
Spread core equity holdings across at least 2 different fund houses with contrasting styles (e.g., one Value/Contrarian house like Parag Parikh or Quantum + one Growth/Momentum house like Mirae or Quant).
2. Limit to Max 2 Schemes Per AMC
Never hold more than 2 schemes in the same AMC unless one is equity and the other is a debt/liquid fund for emergency parking.
3. Run an Overlap Audit Before Adding Scheme #3
If you already hold an AMC flagship flexi-cap, verify its statutory overlap before buying their thematic or large-cap fund.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is it dangerous if an AMC collapses like Franklin Templeton did?
Franklin Templeton faced liquidity redemption issues in debt credit-risk funds, not equity. Equity funds are legally held in separate trusts under SEBI custody. Your equities cannot disappear, but operational and style freeze risks exist.
What is the ideal number of AMCs for a ₹5L - ₹25L portfolio?
Two to three AMCs provide optimal style diversification without creating administrative headache.
Can I switch between funds in the same AMC without paying tax?
No. Under Indian income tax law, switching between schemes—even within the same AMC—is legally treated as a redemption and attracts capital gains tax.

Explore Other Common Investor Questions